"It's been a long time coming," South Windsor planning director Michele Lipe told the Hartford Business Journal in late August, after the developer behind the former Geissler's plaza on Sullivan Avenue started the approval process again. Most of the coverage since then has led with the 125 apartments. The plan's shape gets less attention. The 1965 shopping center that housed the supermarket stays standing. So do the old gas station building and the bank building. Only one building comes down.
That changes what the plaza turns into. It gets renovated rather than rebuilt from scratch, and the part that will matter most on an ordinary weekday is the big commercial building. Right now nobody has publicly signed on to fill it.
A flagship that went dark in July 2025
Geissler's closed its Sullivan Avenue store on July 17, 2025, nearly 40 years after it opened in 1988. The company had long thought of it as a "flagship store" for the chain, the CT Post reported. Company leadership said closing it was "the most responsible step forward to ensure the long-term health of the company." Geissler's president Bob Rydick said he felt close to this store in particular because he started his career in its produce department.
At the time, the company said its closest remaining stores to South Windsor are in Windsor and Somers. By the end of August 2026, the Hartford Business Journal was describing the whole site as a "vacant shopping plaza previously anchored by a Geissler's Supermarket."
What stays, what goes
The applicant is REESG Properties LLC, and the Hartford Business Journal identifies its principal as attorney Eliot B. Gersten. The proposal merges three parcels at 959, 1017 and 1079 Sullivan Ave. into one development site of about 19 acres. Here is how the existing buildings fare under the current plan:
| Existing building | Built | Size | Under the plan |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shopping center, former Geissler's anchor | 1965 | 50,372 sq ft | Kept, renovated |
| Former service station | 1958 | 1,984 sq ft | Kept, renovated |
| Bank building | 1990 | 2,552 sq ft | Kept, renovated |
| Former Hot Leathers store | 1970 | 5,040 sq ft | Demolished for apartments |
The new construction goes up where the Hot Leathers building stood at 1017 Sullivan Ave. Four three-story apartment buildings are planned, two with 36 units each, one with 41 and one with 12, for a total of 125. A clubhouse and pool are also part of the plan. Plans shown to the town's Architectural and Design Review Committee in 2021 described a clubhouse of about 3,400 square feet with a fitness center, leasing office, game room, event space and café next to the pool.
The shopping center keeps its footprint but gets a new face. The plan calls for varied materials, rooflines and masonry to break up the long storefront so it reads more like a streetscape. If the plan goes ahead, people driving down Sullivan Avenue will still see the plaza where it has always been, with a different exterior.
Five years stuck on a sidewalk, not on the apartments
None of this is a new idea. The Planning and Zoning Commission approved the zone change and general plan of development on June 8, 2021. That approval covered 125 apartments and the renovation of 60,740 square feet of commercial space across the same three addresses, and the applicant then was REESG Newco South Windsor, LLC. It came through the Sullivan Avenue Mixed Use Development Overlay Zone, which the town's design committee reviewed for this property in March 2021.
The 2021 approval included a condition that sent the case to court. The developer was told to work with the state Department of Transportation on a sidewalk linking the plaza to Ayers Road. The developer challenged that condition in court, arguing that it depended on action outside the town's control. A stipulated agreement approved in 2023 settled the dispute by replacing the sidewalk requirement with an ornamental fence along Sullivan Avenue.
The 2021 general plan had already settled the mix of 125 apartments and renovated retail, with engineering and site-design details left for a later site-plan review. The fight was over a pedestrian connection that needed the state's cooperation. After the settlement, the project still saw what the Hartford Business Journal called "several years of little visible activity" before REESG filed its wetlands application this year. One practical result is that the plan now under review swaps a walkway to Ayers Road for a decorative fence on Sullivan Avenue.
The 50,000 square feet nobody has claimed
The residential part of the plan comes with unit counts by building. The commercial part has nothing comparable. Neither the current application nor the 2026 coverage names a replacement grocer or any other tenant. The Hartford Business Journal reports that the shopping center's interior spaces would be "reconfigured as tenants are secured."
The 2021 version had a few more specifics. A Hartford Courant report that April described ideas for a convenience store in the former service station and a fast-food restaurant with a drive-through in the bank building, plus general retail and service uses in the rest of the plaza. Those were concepts from five years ago. Nothing in this year's filings shows that any of those uses are lined up now.
So the apartments are the most fully defined part of the project, and the old supermarket box is the least. Whether the anchor space becomes one large tenant or gets split into smaller storefronts will depend on leasing. The application doesn't decide that.
What still has to happen before anything is built
Even with the 2021 approval, a lot of process remains. That approval was conceptual. It required a later site-plan submission that would address phasing. The steps from here:
- Inland Wetlands review. The town received application 26-22W on Sept. 2, 2026, and set the public hearing for Oct. 7. The agency meets that Wednesday at 7 p.m. in the Madden Room at Town Hall, 1540 Sullivan Ave.
- Planning and Zoning site-plan approval. The commission has to approve detailed site plans.
- Water Pollution Control Authority approval. This is required in addition to the wetlands and zoning reviews.
As of the September Patch report, the Inland Wetlands Agency had not yet approved the project. Neither the town's pending-applications listing nor the 2026 coverage gives a construction start or completion date. Pending applications are posted on the Inland Wetlands Agency's pending applications page. That page lists the application number and hearing date, and it's the place to check whether the Oct. 7 hearing is continued or closed.
Residents who want to comment on the stormwater and wetlands side of the plan can do so at Town Hall on the evening of Oct. 7. Questions about building design, phasing and storefronts belong at the later Planning and Zoning site-plan review.
For more on how the Sullivan Avenue corridor fits into the rest of town, see our South Windsor neighborhood page.
If you own a home near Sullivan Avenue and want to know how nearby activity like this redevelopment shows up in what buyers are paying today, The Knurek Team can walk you through recent sales around you. Get your free home valuation and we'll go over the numbers with you, plainly and with no pressure.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.