Bright traditional living room with an oatmeal sofa, pale paneled walls and a level opening to a small dining nook, with late-autumn trees outside.

Why South Windsor Downsizers Have So Few Single-Level Homes to Buy

In September 2026, a South Windsor single-family home went from listing to sale in a median of 15 days and sold for 102.6% of its list price. In the same month, the whole town had six townhouses and condos for sale, which is half a month of supply. For a long-time owner who wants to sell the colonial and stay in town, those two numbers are the problem. The sale side moves fast, and the buy side has almost nothing on it.

The town doesn't look short on senior housing. As of May 30, 2025, South Windsor had 1,280 age-restricted and assisted-living units built or approved, about 10% of its housing stock, according to the Journal Inquirer. The consultant for a new 55-plus proposal gives a very different figure. "Only 4% of South Windsor's housing stock are 55+ units, while 30% of our residents are 55 years of age or older," Design Professionals wrote in a memo quoted by the Hartford Courant. The gap between the two comes from what kind of housing each one counts.

What the 1,280 units actually are

The Journal Inquirer breaks the town's total into categories.

Category Examples named Units Can a downsizer buy one?
Assisted and independent living Alto, Evergreen Crossing 511 No, these are care and service residences
Deed-restricted apartments Berry Patch 356 No, rental
Town-owned apartments Flax Hill, Wapping Mews 70 No, rental
Age-restricted condominium Strawberry Fields 43 Yes
Completed senior residence developments 15 small projects, 3 to 25 units each 250 Yes
Senior residence development, approved March 2025 Orchard Pointe, Foster Street 50 Yes

Add up the last three rows and you get 343 units built to be owned. That is about a quarter of the total. The other 937 are apartments or care residences. These serve real needs, but they don't help a homeowner who wants to trade a four-bedroom house for a smaller home they own.

The 250 units in the fifth row carry a second limit. All 15 of those developments were proposed between 1992 and 2009. The most recent of those proposals dates to 2009.

Why the pipeline stopped, and how it restarted

Planning Director Michele Lipe explained the gap to the Journal Inquirer. "Senior residence developments," the town's term for for-sale, age-restricted housing, were removed from the zoning regulations for some years, so developers had no way to propose them. The rules have changed three times since:

  1. March 2023. The Planning and Zoning Commission brought back senior residence developments as a permitted use when it lifted a housing moratorium enacted a year earlier. Projects were capped at 25 units, with size restrictions and a requirement that 15% of units be deed-restricted as affordable.
  2. September 2024. A developer-proposed amendment allowed larger units and up to 50 units, depending on lot size.
  3. Months later. Another amendment raised the maximum to 72 units.

"The numbers are growing quicker because now there's bigger proposals that can come in," Lipe said in the same article.

The town also has its own reason to be open to this kind of housing. Lipe told the Journal Inquirer that the district's school-age population has been a challenge and that "single-family housing is a higher generator of children than, obviously, a senior residential development is." So when a downsizer moves from a single-family house into a senior residence development, the town gains on two counts. The family house goes back on the market, and the new unit adds to the tax base without adding students.

The timeline also explains why demand has built up. Jim Newbury, the lifelong resident behind the newest proposal, told the Journal Inquirer that many of his friends with grown children had trouble downsizing without leaving South Windsor. "Since there's been a ban ... there's a pent-up demand," he said.

Orchard Pointe is the test case

The first project under the new rules is Orchard Pointe, Boynton Construction's 50-home, 55-plus community at 186 Foster Street. It has single-family homes and villas of about 1,550 to 2,400 square feet. The Hartford Courant reported that the town approved it in March 2025 as for-sale homes, with eight of the 50 set aside as affordable.

How those homes sell matters to everyone else in the pipeline. Lipe said demand exists, but that some developers who had been "gung-ho" had cooled as the wider housing market changed. In July 2025 she told the Journal Inquirer:

"I don't know if you'll see more projects come in quickly or if you'll see a lull, but they're all looking at the one on Foster Street to see how the sales go."

Sales at Foster Street are the evidence other builders will use to decide whether to file the next application.

The Estates at 100 Oakland, the next application

The largest for-sale proposal now before the town is the Estates at 100 Oakland. It calls for 69 single-story homes on 32.53 acres at 15 Petersen Way, 50 Darlene Drive, and 80, 90 and 100 Oakland Road, north of Route 30. Jim and Judith Newbury, who live on the property, are the applicants, as South Windsor Patch reported.

At 69 homes, the plan sits just under the town's 72-unit cap. According to site plans the Courant cited, it would offer three home types:

Home type Size Garage
Detached 1,615 to 2,295 sq ft Attached two-car
Duplex 1,202 to 1,606 sq ft One- or two-car
Triplex, one building 1,202 sq ft One-car

Every home would be a ranch with two or three bedrooms and two full bathrooms. The applicants' consultant says each front door would be one step up to a porch and a second step into the house, with the same two-step limit from the garage. Many homes would also have walk-out basements. The community would have a homeowners association, private roads off Oakland Road, sidewalks, and a trail with fitness stations. Eleven homes would be priced as affordable to buyers earning up to 80% of area median income, with deed restrictions lasting 40 years, according to the Courant's report on the application.

Here is where the application stands as of this week:

  • Wetlands. The Inland Wetlands Agency/Conservation Commission approved it on June 17, 2026. Conditions include a $100,000 erosion-control bond, a $150,000 stormwater-structure bond, a $5,000 wetland-planting bond, and removal of Japanese knotweed.
  • Design review. The applicants report a favorable recommendation from the Architectural & Design Review Committee after its Oct. 15 review.
  • Zoning. The Planning and Zoning Commission scheduled a Nov. 10 public hearing on a special exception to Table 3.1.1A and Section 7.17, plus site plan approval. The application is a special exception, not a zone change.

The project has drawn organized comment. The South Windsor Initiative for Thoughtful Growth has raised concerns about forest clearing, wildlife habitat, stormwater runoff, traffic, and the single entrance on Oakland Road. The group reports that 522 residents signed its petition on the earlier wetlands application. In the June minutes, wetlands commissioners said their decision had to focus on wetlands impacts. They described the planned bridge and stream restoration as beneficial if built properly.

What sits behind those two projects

Beyond Foster Street and Oakland Road, the largest concept is Wheeler Road Carriage Home Restricted Housing. Downeast LLC, an affiliate of Washington Prime Group, has proposed a 210-unit age-restricted community at 22 Wheeler Road and 281, 285 and 367 Smith Street. The plan needs a zone change of about 45 acres to the Buckland Gateway South Overlay Zone, and the Planning and Zoning Commission opened its hearing on Jan. 13, 2026. The Courant described the units as age-restricted condos. The January minutes also say a general plan does not replace a site plan. A full site plan would still have to be submitted and approved before construction could start.

The town's 343 ownable age-restricted units already include Orchard Pointe. If Oakland Road and Wheeler Road were both approved and built, they would add 279 more, bringing the total to 622. Both still need zoning approvals, and Wheeler Road would also need an approved full site plan before construction could start.

What this means for a sale this winter

In the SmartMLS numbers, the condo category covers every townhouse and condo in town, not only age-restricted ones, and that category is the one that has tightened. In September 2026, inventory stood at six listings, down from 14 a year earlier. The year-to-date condo median price through September was $337,500, up 21.1% from the same period in 2025. SmartMLS warns that percentage changes can look extreme with small samples. Still, a 0.5-month supply means a buyer is competing for whatever single-level unit lists next.

The single-family side looks different. September 2026 closings had a median sale price of $501,000 and spent 15 days on market, against 1.9 months of supply. A downsizer's family home is likely to sell quickly. The difficult part is timing that sale with the purchase of a smaller home. Builder purchase agreements, HOA documents, and the 40-year deed restrictions on affordable units each have their own terms. This post is general information and not legal, tax or financial advice, so confirm how any of these terms apply to you with an attorney or lender before signing.

FAQ

Is an age-restricted community the same as assisted living? No. In South Windsor's count, assisted and independent living facilities such as Alto and Evergreen Crossing are a separate category from for-sale senior residence developments such as Orchard Pointe.

Where can I read the Oakland Road application? The Planning and Zoning Commission's legal notice lists Application 26-29P. It says copies are on file with the Town Clerk and the Planning Department and are also posted on the town's website.

Do the new projects include affordable homes? Yes. Orchard Pointe sets aside eight of its 50 homes, and the Estates at 100 Oakland proposes 11 of its 69. The Journal Inquirer reported that the town's senior residence rules have required 15% of units to be deed-restricted as affordable since they were reinstated in 2023.

If you own a South Windsor home and are deciding whether to sell before or after these projects arrive, The Knurek Team can price your home against current local sales and map out a sale timeline that fits your next purchase. Start with a free home valuation, and see our seller's guide for what happens after the sign goes up.

Work With Us

Etiam non quam lacus suspendisse faucibus interdum. Orci ac auctor augue mauris augue neque. Bibendum at varius vel pharetra. Viverra orci sagittis eu volutpat. Platea dictumst vestibulum rhoncus est pellentesque elit ullamcorper.

Follow Me on Instagram