Thin-crust tomato and mozzarella pizza on a white platter at a softly lit window table with blue-gray seating in a neighborhood pizzeria.

South Windsor Pizza, Sorted by Style, With Two Big Names on the Way

Buckland Grill & Pizza at 465 Buckland Road puts a classic New Haven-style pizza on its menu next to burgers and dinner specials. A short drive up the same corridor, Sally's Apizza has a building permit for an empty 5,000-square-foot building at 5 Cedar Avenue near Evergreen Walk. The Journal Inquirer reported the permit after Town Manager Michael Maniscalco's report to the Town Council on Sept. 21, 2026. Across the street, at the Mason's Row development, Colony Grill has signed on to bring its hot oil pies.

The two best-known pizza names headed to town are both going to the Buckland Road side. South Windsor's established shops each work in a different style, and each sits on a different road. Ellington Road has the New York and Sicilian slices, Oakland Road has thin crust and Detroit, and Buckland Road is where New Haven-style will get crowded once Sally's opens. Here's the map, road by road, ahead of the Thanksgiving weekend.

Ellington Road: New York-style and Sicilian since 2000

Sal's Pizzeria is in the Town Center plaza at 1735 Ellington Road. Owner Sal Mazzarella told South Windsor Patch in 2020 that his family came to America from Sicily when he was 14. He started in food service as a baker at Modern Pastry in Hartford and opened the restaurant in 2000. The shop's current website lists New York-style and Sicilian pizza, with takeout and delivery, under an "EST. 2000" banner.

Sal's has also been recognized outside town. When Connecticut Magazine published its unranked statewide readers' picks for best pizza in February 2016, Sal's New York Style Pizza was the South Windsor entry, as Patch reported at the time. In Patch's 2020 Business of the Year call for nominations, a number of readers named Sal's as the best in town.

Alexia's Pizza & Restaurant is the other long-running family name. Its website says it is family-owned and operated, has served the community since 1993, and is known for its "5lb Pizza." That makes Alexia's seven years older than Sal's, and it's the order to call when a regular pie won't feed the crowd.

Oakland Road: thin crust, Detroit, and a pie named for a mentor

Oakland Pizza Co. at 289 Oakland Road opened in late October 2018 in the former Teddy's Pizza space, so one pizzeria simply replaced another at that address. Owners Camille Malaspina and Dave Noad had opened Camille's Wood-Fired Pizza in Tolland five years earlier. The couple met while working at a Simsbury pizzeria, according to a 2023 Connecticut Magazine profile.

Oakland differs from its Tolland sibling in the oven. The Hartford Courant reported when it opened that Camille's uses a wood-fired oven and Oakland uses a brick one. Because of that, Noad adjusted the menu and offered some pies in 12-inch and 16-inch sizes. Camille's "bacon and eggs" pizza stayed in Tolland because it works best in the wood-fired oven. At opening, the South Windsor menu also had its own supreme pie and a margherita with burrata.

The pie that best explains the kitchen is the Billy's Bianco. It's topped with pistachio, garlic cream sauce, ricotta, goat cheese, red onion and truffle honey. Connecticut Magazine reported that Noad created it as a tribute to his former boss and mentor Billy Grant of the Bricco restaurants in West Hartford and Glastonbury. The spicy roni, with chopped chili peppers, came over from the Tolland menu. Oakland's website now lists crispy Detroit-style pies next to its thin crust, plus craft beer and salads. That makes it the one place on this map with both a thin, artisanal pie and a thick, square-edged one.

Sullivan Avenue: the newest storefront and a short-lived one

Domino's at 154 Sullivan Avenue is the newest pizza storefront in town. The Connecticut Scoop reported in October 2025 that construction was underway at Sullivan Corner Plaza. That same month, students at South Windsor High School wrote about the plans in The Bobcat Prowl. The store's page lists online ordering and daily hours.

Sullivan Avenue had a different pizza tenant not long ago. Joe Pizza opened at 855 Sullivan Avenue in May 2020, and Patch reported in April 2023 that the location had closed. South Windsor Pizza & Restaurant fills out the list of local names, with dine-in, takeout and phone orders at 860-289-1800.

Buckland Road: New Haven-style, with Sally's planned nearby

Buckland Grill & Pizza is the local shop that already makes the style Sally's is famous for. Its website describes the place as a bar and grill with a cozy bar, happy hour, and a new outdoor patio. Its featured pies include the Margherita, the Honey Badger, and the Smashed Potato.

Sally's is the reason most people outside the state know the phrase New Haven-style. Salvatore "Sally" Consiglio founded it on Wooster Street in New Haven in 1938. In 2024, Patch described it as one of "The Holy Trinity" of New Haven pizzerias, along with Frank Pepe's and Modern Apizza. It has since expanded to locations across Connecticut and Massachusetts.

The South Windsor location has been in the works for a while. The Planning and Zoning Commission approved the underlying Evergreen Walk development plan in October 2023. In April 2024, owner O'Evergreen LLC asked to modify that plan for a 5,000-square-foot restaurant, and a filed document referred to Sally's. The town approved the site plan change that month. The Journal Inquirer's account at the time said the "regional chain restaurant" in the filing was in all likelihood Sally's. That same week, Sally's told the paper it had not yet signed a South Windsor lease. In September 2026, Patch reported that the plan was to start interior work around mid-September or October 2026, the latest timeline the town has shared.

If you know Cedar Avenue, you already know the building. It shares an access drive with Starbucks and Cold Stone Creamery at 19 Cedar Ave., the Chipotle building at 11 Cedar Ave., and PeoplesBank at 25 Cedar Ave., closest to Buckland Road.

Across the street: Stamford's hot oil pie

Colony Grill is the other import, and it makes a style nobody in South Windsor has made before. The Connecticut Scoop reported on Sept. 17, 2026 that Colony Grill had signed on at Mason's Row, the development at 190 Buckland Street across from The Shops at Evergreen Walk that was previously called The Gateway. It will bring its signature tavern-style hot oil pies, and the chain is also opening in Newington and Glastonbury. The other signed tenants are NAYA, Dave's Hot Chicken, the Wonder food hall, DORO Marketplace from West Hartford's DORO Restaurant Group, and Club Pilates.

The 2016 Connecticut Magazine readers' list that included Sal's also listed Colony Grill, with its Stamford, Fairfield and Milford locations. Ten years later, both names are part of South Windsor's pizza map.

Reading the map

Once Sally's and Colony Grill are both open, the Buckland Road and Evergreen Walk area will have three distinct pizza traditions within a short drive of one another: Buckland Grill's and Sally's New Haven-style, and Colony Grill's bar pie with hot oil. The rest of town stays spread out. Ellington Road keeps its New York and Sicilian slices, which have been there since 2000. Oakland Road keeps its brick-oven thin crust and its Detroit squares, which have been there since 2018. The 5lb pie at Alexia's dates to 1993. If you're picking for a crowd, the style you want points you to the road. On the Buckland side, though, you'll have to choose which famous name you want.

Knowing which plaza is getting which tenant and how long a project has been in the works is the same street-level knowledge The Knurek Team brings to pricing a South Windsor home. If you're curious how a new restaurant row near you is affecting what your home could sell for, get your free home valuation and we'll walk you through the numbers.

Work With Us

Etiam non quam lacus suspendisse faucibus interdum. Orci ac auctor augue mauris augue neque. Bibendum at varius vel pharetra. Viverra orci sagittis eu volutpat. Platea dictumst vestibulum rhoncus est pellentesque elit ullamcorper.

Follow Me on Instagram